EVANSVILLE — You can always find the highest-paid public employees in Vanderburgh County working in the upper tiers of education. But criminal-justice employees aren’t far behind.

Judges, a public defender, Vanderburgh County Prosecutor Nick Hermann and Sheriff Dave Wedding combined to make up a sizeable portion of the Evansville area’s top earners in 2021.

No one in the top 25 made less than $140,000.

In a list of the top 10 published by the Courier & Press last month, we overlooked Steven Becker, the associate dean of the Indiana University School of Medicine in Downtown Evansville. His $335,327 compensation placed him second overall and bumped Zane Mitchell – dean of the University of Southern Indiana’s Pott College of Science, Engineering and Education – out of the top 10.

More public employee salaries:Here are the highest-paid Vanderburgh County public employees from 2021

The 12th- to 25th-highest earners are listed below.

The list only includes public employees, which means administrators and professors at the University of Evansville, a private institution, aren’t included. Private business leaders don’t qualify either.

If we missed anyone who should have been included, let us know.

12. Nick Hermann

Job: Vanderburgh County prosecutor

Compensation: $164,950

The Vanderburgh County prosecutor was the county's highest-paid elected official in 2021, making about $6,000 more than he did the year before, according to state records. 

Indiana Gateway, the statewide database of public salaries, lists Hermann's compensation as slightly lower, at $163,493. But a letter from Supreme Court Chief Justice Loretta Rush that was sent to the Vanderburgh County Council in April 2021 set the state's compensation for prosecutors at $159,950. Vanderburgh County then kicked in $5,000 toward Hermann's rate, bringing his income to the total above.

13. Les Shively

Job: Superior Court judge

Compensation: $162,543

14. Wayne Trockman

Job: Superior Court judge

Compensation: $162,493

T-15. Mary Margaret Lloyd

Job: Superior Court judge

Compensation: $162,393

T-15. David Kiely

Job: Circuit Court judge

Compensation: $162,393

T-15. Brett Niemeier

Job: Superior Court judge

Compensation: $162,393

T-15. Robert Pigman

Job: Superior Court judge

Compensation: $162,393

19. Gary Schutte

Job: Superior Court judge

Compensation: $162,228

20. Dave Wedding

Job: Vanderburgh County sheriff

Compensation: $161,601

Wedding, who's serving his final year as sheriff, has seen his compensation increase by more than $30,000 in the last five years. State records listed his 2016 income as $126,437.

21. Stephen Owens

Job: Chief public defender

Compensation: $161,124

22. Kenneth Spear

Job: Vanderburgh County Health Department administrator

Compensation: $155,649

23. Brian McGuire

Job: Interim dean of USI’s Romain College of Business

Compensation: $154,114

24. Kevin Celuch

Job: USI marketing professor

Compensation: $143,291

25. Khalilah Doss

Job: USI vice president of student affairs

Compensation: $141,400

© 2025 courierpress.com, All rights reserved.